Arch Evil, on Feb 20 2010, 05:39 AM, said:
Looks like the new album might end up somewhere between 'mediocre' and 'decent', and I'm sad to say this happens a lot nowadays...
It happens a lot to me too. I`ve wondered a few times in the last years if I was the problem or if the issue was really the music itself. Because, 99 out of 100 times, I don`t necessarily think the music is awful (though it also happens) but my reaction is "meh, I heard the same thing hundreds of times before and done in a much better way".
The main problems I have are the softening of many bands and the fact lots of albums nowadays are a watered-down-for-the-masses copy of older albums with a modern production I hate because it sounds sterile, soulless and so damn boring.
Imo, lots of bands (old or new bands) need to put aside the modern production they use if they wish to create music that will give the listener any kind of feeling (other than complete boredom).
Another issue is lots of albums feel so uninspired and bland. Here, I can see three explanations. Either the songwriter has lost inspiration with time and can`t write good songs anymore (it happens quite often with the famous old bands- they`re carried on only by their past because people don`t really analize the new music they make, as if their subconscious tells them that everything made by this band is great by definition so they overlook that the new material sucks), or the songwriter simply has never been good at it and never wrote great songs, or the album has been released only to be released which means no one really put thought in the songwriting (what I sometimes refer to as fast-food metal).
Personally, even if I wondered a few times if I still liked metal, I know the answer now. I still like metal a lot because, when I hear the kind of stuff that suits my tastes, I enjoy it as much as I did 20 years ago. If I so often dislike the new material I hear, it`s either because it`s different and doesn`t suit my tastes or because it quite simply sucks.
For example, I received Hellish Crossfire`s "Bloodrust Scythe" this week. The album sounds very old school. I sat there in my living room and put the CD in my PS3 (I use it as a CD reader sometimes). Guess what? I liked all the songs instantly.
It put a smile on my face because I felt as if I were in some kind of flashback or if I was re-living past events. For a short time, I was the teenage boy who discovers metal and is thrilled about it.
And I still enjoy many genres but almost only old albums. I`m listening to the song "Caught Somewhere In time" while writing this post, if it can give an idea.
So, my conclusion is nothing changed so much in me, even after all those years. If I so often dislike metal nowadays, it`s because it changed and the overall quality decreased. And because it`s overproduced, so it sounds like commercial crap.
Only exception is Powermetal: I grew tired of this genre over the years so much I can`t even enjoy the stuff I liked a decade ago.
Some people here seem to believe I listen only to Black Metal and it`s the sole genre I like. It`s false. I still like Thrash, some classic heavy metal bands, a bit of Death Metal, old progressive hard rock, etc.
The difference is Black Metal is the only genre from which I often like the new stuff. In all other genres, I still enjoy most of the old stuff as much as I did in the 80s but I don`t like the new stuff at all.